6 Comments
User's avatar
Herbert Heyduck's avatar

David, I just need to say this:

Your content and writing style are truly excellent.

Your articles have become so important to me that I find myself checking my inbox multiple times a day just to see if you've written something new. While I don't agree with everything you say, particularly on social policy matters, I still find your thoughts very valuable. I hope you'll continue your work for the foreseeable future. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Devon Philson's avatar

Hits the mark like a photon torpedo to a shuttlepod full of hand-wringing Luddites.

The doomers aren’t fighting for humanity’s future, they’re building personal brands on the back of apocalyptic fanfiction.

AI safety matters, but it needs rigor, not cultish catastrophizing. Otherwise, it’s just “Heaven’s Gate” with more silicon and fewer robes.

Expand full comment
Nathan Lambert's avatar

I see them as people who care about the world going well, but have tunnel vision. Is a common thing, I’d put Zuckerberg’s early years like that too.

Expand full comment
Dan's avatar
Apr 6Edited

Hey Dave, I read the civil and intelligent back and forth you had with Mr. Alexander. I agree with you, but it begs the question, is debate on X, with already made up minds really worth your time and energy?

As another neurodivergent in reset mode, I worry about how this affects your cortisol levels and how much good it does for your internal reality?

You’re so good at synthesizing and articulating truly life changing concepts that positively impact a pretty underserved spectrum of humanity, this just seems like a little step backwards.

Maybe I’m full of shit and if you’re getting something positive from these exchanges, then by all means, you do you.

As long as humans are wired to prioritize fear and threat, lame people will harness them to gain status and reproductive advantage. Luckily we don’t need that shit to find mates and friends 😂🚀

Expand full comment
JstarPri's avatar

Dave what’s your opinion on Gary Marcus’ view on GenAI? I haven’t yet decided if he’s Paul Party Pooper or Realistic Rick. Both?

Do you know if there’s been any work made public from experiments of allowing frontier class models (freshly trained) to manage their own weights and what not?

Like, I get that we all are opining about what’s in front of our faces, but I’m super curious what’s actually behind the corporate veil.

What are these models truly capable of if allowed to operate without guardrails? There’s got to be some efforts there, right?

Expand full comment
David Shapiro's avatar

I've had to unfollow Gary on all platforms because he rarely makes sense. It's like his entire career is taking potshots at little gimmes and gotchas in the AI space.

Expand full comment